Democratising aortic valve repair: from “I do it my way” to an expert consensus

This EACTS consensus document sets out how to assess anatomy, choose a technique for aortic valve repair or aortic root replacement with preservation of the native valve, and judge whether the result is likely to be reproducible and durable.

Aortic valve repair (AVr) and aortic root replacement with preservation of the native valve (VSARR) are established options in selected patients, but their use still depends heavily on the experience of each team. Anatomical diversity, the different mechanisms of aortic regurgitation (AR) and the interplay between the cusps and the root make it difficult to define a uniform strategy. Preserving the valve requires an understanding of which components have lost function and which can be reconstructed with a reasonable prospect of durability.

For years, these procedures seemed to be the preserve of a few surgeons, some of whom developed their own technical variations on the same operation. The document by De Paulis et al., produced under the auspices of EACTS, addresses these issues through an extensive review of the evidence and a series of consensus statements. The panel brings together leading experts, including Dr Alberto Forteza from Spain. The methods included a systematic literature review and anonymous voting, with at least 80% participation and at least 75% agreement required for each statement. The document covers functional anatomy, imaging, patient selection, surgical techniques, assessment of the result and the organisational requirements of specialist centres.

Its central premise is that repair must restore the function of the cusps and the aortic root as a unit. This means correcting the mechanism of regurgitation, achieving adequate coaptation and stabilising the dilated components of the functional annulus. The statements offer practical guidance and should be interpreted as expert consensus informed by evidence of variable quality, with few randomised comparisons and substantial differences among the reported populations and techniques.

The panel considers patient selection, preoperative imaging and intraoperative assessment of the repair essential. For aortic root replacement with preservation of the native valve, reimplantation and remodelling with annuloplasty yield comparable outcomes over the medium and long term. Durability depends on valve anatomy, tissue quality and repair technique.

COMMENTARY:

One of the document’s main contributions is to provide a systematic anatomical assessment of whether a valve can be repaired. Its figures and tables lay out a sequence that can be applied in practice: identify the phenotype, assess the available tissue, choose a reconstruction and determine whether the result justifies preserving the valve.

The analysis of the bicuspid aortic valve (BAV) is one of the most detailed sections. Its anatomy lies on a continuum, from phenotypes with partial fusion resembling a tricuspid aortic valve (TAV) to nearly symmetrical valves with two sinuses. Between these extremes, the length of fusion, the height of the commissure that is no longer functional and the orientation of the functional commissures vary. Describing which cusps are fused is therefore insufficient for planning a repair. The classification used to guide repair distinguishes three groups according to the commissural angle of the cusp without fusion: type A, symmetrical, at 160° to 180°, type B, asymmetrical, at 140° to 159°, and type C, very asymmetrical, at 120° to 139°. The angle is measured on the cusp without fusion. The classification links the echocardiographic image to the geometry the surgeon will encounter and to the complexity of reconstruction.

Symmetrical valves generally offer a more favourable substrate. In very asymmetrical valves, the fused cusp may be restricted at the raphe, requiring a more complex repair or replacement. The angle is one element in the decision. Its value comes from assessing it alongside tissue quantity, cusp mobility, calcification and root configuration. An apparently favourable anatomy may be unsuitable for repair if the tissue is damaged.

Another section expands on this selection process. Pliable cusps, prolapse and abnormal root geometry with preserved valve tissue favour repair. Severe regurgitation alone does not preclude repair. Intrinsic restriction, marked retraction, extensive calcification, large or multiple perforations and destructive endocarditis favour replacement.

A localised lesion may still be compatible with repair. Calcification confined to the raphe, a small defect or a commissural fenestration can allow valve preservation. The decision depends on how much functional tissue remains and what reconstruction would be required. The threshold for proceeding should be higher when valve preservation requires replacing a substantial portion of the cusp surface with patch material.

Geometric height (gH) provides an objective measure for this assessment. The document considers values of at least 17 mm for TAV and 20 mm for BAV favourable, with 16 mm and 19 mm, respectively, regarded as borderline. The intraoperative checklist takes a more conservative position and places these borderline values among the findings that favour replacement. These thresholds help identify a tissue deficit and should be interpreted in the context of the individual anatomy.

The same checklist brings the assessment into the operating room. Direct inspection should confirm the phenotype, cusp size and configuration, thickening, calcification, retraction and the extent of fenestrations and perforations. Prolapse with sufficient tissue (type II mechanism) is a very different finding from a retracted cusp with restricted mobility (type III mechanism), even though both cause AR.

The way the valve is inspected also matters. The consensus recommends exposing it with commissural traction sutures pulled outwards, following the anatomical orientation and avoiding asymmetrical tension. Poor exposure can distort the geometry being assessed. Reparability should be confirmed by a reproducible assessment that complements transoesophageal echocardiography (TOE) and the preoperative findings.

Two measurements address different questions. Geometric height indicates how much tissue is available. Effective height (eH) describes the position of the free margin relative to the annular plane. Reduced eH may reveal a correctable prolapse. Insufficient gH points to a tissue deficit that simply shortening the free margin cannot correct. The Schäfers calliper is particularly useful in this assessment. An eH <9 mm may indicate prolapse of that cusp.

For root replacement, the key statement considers reimplantation and remodelling with circumferential annuloplasty equivalent. The addition of annuloplasty is essential. In reimplantation, the graft stabilises the annulus. With remodelling, the annulus must be addressed separately to achieve a stable reconstruction. The statement applies to remodelling with annuloplasty, and it does not establish identical results across all anatomies and observation periods.

The shared principle is to correct annular dilatation and restore an appropriate relationship with the sinotubular junction (STJ). The consensus recommends subvalvular circumferential annuloplasty and advises against relying on subcommissural sutures as the primary method of stabilisation. This also applies to isolated repair. Correcting a cusp while leaving the annulus dilated can leave a cause of late failure untreated.

Root reconstruction also alters valve geometry. Reducing root dimensions can induce or unmask prolapse, so eH and coaptation must be reassessed after root replacement. A properly reconstructed root alone cannot ensure valve competence. The document gives limited direction on graft selection. It does not favour a particular reimplantation variant, such as David I, David V or a Valsalva graft, and leaves room for different sizing practices. It reports that 30 mm is the most commonly used adult size for reimplantation and 28 mm for remodelling, and notes that BAV may require a larger graft than TAV. In my own practice with the David V technique, these sizes seem small. For aneurysmal roots, a 34 mm graft, or 32 mm in smaller patients, may help restore eH when the cusps have enlarged along with the root. Using a smaller graft based on the height of the commissural post between the left coronary and noncoronary cusps, as in the David procedure with a Valsalva graft, leads to sizes closer to those described in the document but can require more plication of the free margin to restore eH. In my practice, I use the same measurement to estimate the target STJ size, which guides the choice of the second graft for ascending aortic replacement. I interpret this measurement alongside the eH achieved. With adequate eH, the planned STJ size can be retained. With borderline eH, reducing the STJ with a David V reconstruction can induce prolapse, and a David I may be preferable to additional plication of the free margin.

Central cusp plication is presented as the most widely used and reliable technique for correcting prolapse. Shortening or reinforcing the free margin, selectively treating the raphe and closing small defects extend the options for valve preservation. Patches may be required, particularly for perforations or localised tissue deficits, but their use is associated with a higher risk of failure, especially in BAV. The document acknowledges that the effect of patch material is difficult to separate from that of a more complex underlying lesion. The document also discusses rigid subvalvular annuloplasty rings, including the HAART 200 and 300, which may have a role in isolated AVr without root replacement.

The document makes a further practical point about assessment after repair. The result should be accepted on objective criteria. The degree of residual AR is only one of these criteria. Assessment takes place after separation from cardiopulmonary bypass under physiological loading conditions. The aim is no AR, trivial AR or at most mild central AR, a coaptation height of at least 4 mm and an eH of at least 9 mm. The mean gradient should be 15 mmHg or less and the peak gradient 30 mmHg or less, with preserved cusp mobility and no residual prolapse.

Jet direction deserves as much attention as jet severity. Mild eccentric AR may indicate a persistent structural defect and warrant revision. A competent valve with restricted cusp motion and a high gradient is also an unsatisfactory result. The consensus considers more than mild AR an indication for a second period of aortic clamping to revise the repair or replace the valve. It favours a lower threshold for eccentric jets given their adverse prognostic implications.

The table also provides reference values for residual annular diameter: 21 to 24 mm is acceptable, 25 mm is borderline and 26 to 27 mm warrants concern. These values should be interpreted in light of the individual patient and reconstruction. The goal is to stabilise the annulus without excessively narrowing the orifice. Geometry, competence and valve opening should be assessed together, as no single measurement guarantees durability.

Finally, the document defines an aortic centre of excellence by more than the presence of a surgeon who can repair the valve. It requires a multidisciplinary team, advanced imaging, standardised communication between the surgeon and imaging specialist, technical expertise and longitudinal surveillance. The document mentions an initial experience of 40 to 60 procedures to achieve stable results. Quality should be demonstrated through mortality, complications, residual AR, reinterventions and serial echocardiography, supported by a registry and review of outcomes.

The consensus sets out the conditions under which preserving an aortic valve is worthwhile. Anatomical selection, root stabilisation and rigorous assessment of the result are parts of the same strategy. Expanding access to repair also requires recognising when the available tissue or geometry precludes a durable result. Excellence lies in achieving a good repair and in knowing when replacement is the sounder decision.

REFERENCE:

De Paulis R, Folino G, Berrebi A, Casselman FPA, Cerqueira RJ, Della Corte A, et al. EACTS Expert Consensus Document on aortic valve repair and valve-sparing aortic root replacement procedures. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2026;68(10):ezag182. doi:10.1093/ejcts/ezag182.

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR MONTHLY NEWSLETTER..
XXVIII Resident Course
Get to know our magazine

Comparte esta información